1943 Steel Penny Found in Rusty Tackle Box Brings Unexpected $875,000 Windfall

In a small Midwest town, an old fishing tackle box tucked away in a dusty garage turned into a life-changing discovery

What started as a routine cleanup turned into a jaw-dropping moment for one Missouri man. Buried beneath a tangle of rusted fishing hooks and worn bobbers was a hidden gem that would make collectors around the world take notice—a rare 1943 steel penny, later auctioned for an astonishing $875,000.

The story is the kind of real-life treasure hunt that feels straight out of a movie—and it’s sparking new interest in coin collecting across the country.

A Coin Hidden in Plain Sight

The incredible find was made by 72-year-old Frank M., a retired postal worker going through his late father’s garage. In a dusty old fishing tackle box, he found a tiny compartment filled with wax paper-wrapped coins. Among them was a dull, silver-toned penny that looked completely out of place.

Unlike the copper coins he was used to seeing, this one was lighter and had a different shine. Curious, Frank took it to a local coin dealer, never expecting what would happen next.

The dealer’s reaction said it all. Frank had unknowingly stumbled upon a 1943 steel Lincoln penny—an ultra-rare coin that holds a special place in U.S. history.

What Makes the 1943 Steel Penny So Special?

During World War II, copper was a critical material needed for military equipment, especially ammunition. To preserve copper for the war effort, the U.S. Mint made a bold move in 1943—producing pennies from zinc-coated steel instead.

Over a billion of these steel cents were minted, but many didn’t survive. They rusted, were discarded, or were confused with dimes due to their silvery color. That’s why finding one in pristine condition, with clear details and no rust, is such a big deal today.

While most 1943 steel pennies are only worth a few cents to a few dollars, exceptional examples—like Frank’s—can fetch a small fortune. Coins with sharp details, no corrosion, and rare minting errors are especially prized.

Auction Bidding War Takes Off

After professional grading confirmed the coin’s top-tier condition, it was listed at a major coin auction house. What followed surprised even seasoned collectors.

Initial bids were modest, but interest quickly surged. The auction became a global event as collectors from around the world battled to claim the rare penny. In the end, the coin sold for an eye-popping $875,000 to a private buyer.

It was far more than Frank had imagined. “I thought it might buy me lunch,” he said with a laugh. “I never dreamed it would change my retirement.”

A Life-Changing Surprise

Frank’s story quickly went viral, capturing the imagination of people across the country. His simple act of cleaning out a garage led to a life-changing windfall, proving that history—and hidden value—can show up when you least expect it.

The buzz around his find has inspired others to dig through their old change jars, check family heirlooms, and explore forgotten corners of garages and attics. You never know what might be waiting.

Why You Might Still Find One

Here’s the surprising part: 1943 steel pennies weren’t exactly rare when they were minted. They were everyday currency. And while many were lost or damaged, some still exist in the wild—stored in coffee cans, coin albums, or, yes, even tackle boxes.

Experts say you should keep an eye out for silver-colored pennies from 1943. A true steel cent won’t be attracted to a magnet and is noticeably lighter than the traditional copper ones. Just remember—not all 1943 pennies are valuable. It takes rarity, top condition, or a unique minting error to push the value sky-high.

Final Thoughts

The tale of Frank and his steel penny reminds us that history isn’t always locked behind museum glass—it could be tucked away in your own home. His incredible discovery not only changed his life but also reignited excitement for coin collecting nationwide.

So next time you’re cleaning out an old drawer or sorting through family keepsakes, take a closer look. You might just find a forgotten piece of history worth a fortune.

FAQs